Vascular Access: Reducing Catheter Contact Time to Improve Clinical Outcomes and Reduce Cost of Care

Sample image
Sample image

Although three of the nine touch points are listed under the dialysis clinic, the success of the clinic's outcomes is directly related to the access management team's dedication to catheter reduction. Many of the catheter removal delays can be eliminated by focusing on providing prompt service to reduce scheduling times. This focus on time metrics, coupled with promptly identifying access dysfunction prior to thrombosis through surveillance and monitoring, will pave the way for improving total catheter contact time and access vintage and reducing missed treatments. To ensure informed decisions and facilitate collaboration, the quality measures for vascular surgeons and access center interventionalists could be provided to dialysis centers and nephrologists.

ONE-STOP SHOP

Providing the ESRD patient with a "one-stop shop" for all their access needs (from creation to maintenance and salvage) allows for improved care coordination for timely catheter removal. Pilot studies performed in collaboration with Fresenius Kidney Care have shown that providing access creation in the access center setting can reduce catheter contact time by up to 29 percent.3,4 In addition, providing access care in a freestanding access center reduces infection rates, hospitalizations, and mortality, as well as the total cost of care.5 This is one of the leading reasons Azura is converting most of its access centers to Ambulatory Surgery Centers (ASC).

Incorporating vascular surgeons into Azura's ASC structure means the patient will navigate fewer providers and clinic locations to achieve timely catheter removal. The ASC model will also allow Azura to utilize two exciting and transformative technologies: percutaneous fistula creation and, potentially, the HumacyteTM human acellular vessel. 

PERCUTANEOUS FISTULA CREATION

Percutaneous anastomosis devices were approved in June 2018 for use as an alternative to surgical fistula creation in the United States.6,7 Early studies suggest these percutaneous fistulas are comparable to surgically created fistulas on measures such as technical and clinical success; however, they may require maturation procedures. Additionally, the limited acceptable anatomical locations may preclude the use of this technique in many patients requiring an access.

Demonstrated advantages of endovascular fistula creation include the ability to perform AV access creation in an outpatient setting utilizing a minimally invasive technique, thus widening the group of physicians able to create functional AV fistulas. In addition, access creation in the vascular access center will improve access to care while reducing patient wait times.

These advantages may contribute significantly to patient satisfaction as well as increasing AVF prevalence and reducing CVC contact time for ESRD patients.

Seven Azura centers have been designated pilot sites for this exciting and important project. More than a half dozen physicians are currently being trained on the use of these devices. Between Azura centers in San Antonio, Texas, and Woodland Park, New Jersey, 50-plus successful percutaneous fistulas have already been placed. Furthermore, the transition to the ASC model will allow Azura interventional physicians and vascular surgeons to create fistulas on an outpatient basis.

HUMACYTETM HUMAN ACELLULAR VESSEL

Fresenius Medical Care North America (FMCNA) has partnered with HumacyteTM, the developers of the novel bioengineered human acellular vessel named Humacyl®. Humacyl® has been designated a biologic that offers off-the-shelf availability and, potentially, superior clinical efficacy and safety as compared with polytetrafluoroethylene grafts (pending the results of investigative trials), with the regenerative properties of a fistula. Humacyl® is grown in vitro from banked human aortic smooth muscle cells. These smooth muscle cells are placed on a tubular scaffold made of biodegradable material (Figure 2). Cells on the scaffold multiply, generating extracellular matrix proteins during the culture in a closed bioreactor system. Material from original donor cells that can trigger an immune response is then removed from the HAV matrix. The result is the Humacyl® human acellular vessel (Figure 3). Early patient data indicates that once implanted, the HAV is remodeled by the host patient to create a vascular structure similar to native vascular tissue. 

FIGURE 2 | Grow in vitro to form a biologic 3D scaffold

Sample image

FIGURE 3 | Humacyl® human acellular vessel (HAV)

Sample image

Investigational studies have demonstrated that the Humacyl® can be cannulated four weeks after placement. With this early cannulation, CVC contact time can potentially be reduced—in turn, reducing complications of CVC, such as infection and central venous stenosis.8 Since the HAV is acellular and created from biologic human smooth muscle cells, Humacyl® is not immunogenic. This essentially eliminates the risk of rejection. In addition, Humacyl® has a decreased risk of infection, in comparison with traditional grafts, reducing the potential for catheter reinsertion. 

ECONOMIC IMPACT OF CATHETERS

The economic impact of hemodialysis catheter use is considerable. In a study based on CMS data and hospital costs reported by the Kaiser Family Foundation and American Hospital Association, for "urgent start" hemodialysis patients (those requiring either temporary or tunneled hemodialysis catheters immediately and typically in a hospital-based setting), total inpatient and outpatient costs were $19,352 per patient for the first 90 days, plus an additional $8,053 per patient for the first 90 days of dialysis services.9,10 Considering 80 percent of the estimated 124,675 incident ESRD patients begin treatment with HD catheters, the cost impacts are truly staggering, at approximately $3.4 billion for the first 90 days and an additional estimated $800 million for dialysis services. When adding prevalent ESRD patients to these estimates, it becomes clear that HD catheter-based dialysis represents an unacceptably large percentage of the $114 billion annual Medicare ESRD/chronic kidney disease spending.11

Azura is committed to reducing this economic burden through a variety of pathways, including outpatient PD catheter placement, which is a more patient-centered, more comfortable, and more efficient way to begin dialysis. It also represents a significant cost savings, with potential decreased costs of approximately $3,000 per incident patient in the first 90 days and $200 per incident patient for dialysis services over the same period of time. Of course, this thought experiment assumes that all of the 80 percent incident ESRD patients beginning dialysis with a hemodialysis catheter change to PD. This assumption is somewhat unrealistic for a variety of medical, anatomic, and patient- and physician training-related reasons, but it still underscores the cost savings that may be recognized by Azura's determination to expand PD catheter placement options nationally.

To succeed at reducing catheter contact time, vascular access management requires coordinating multiple complex processes. These processes must be continually monitored and enhanced through data-driven analytics, best practices, and evidence-based quality improvement initiatives, thereby allowing all stakeholders to make informed decisions. Implementing the nine touch points of vascular access quality improvement, coupled with improved care coordination and adoption of new technologies in the "one-stop shop" ASC model, will help Azura achieve the vision of one access for a lifetime.

Meet Our Experts

MURAT SOR, MD
Chief Medical Officer, Azura Vascular Care

A graduate of the University of Pennsylvania, Murat Sor is certified by the American Board of Radiology, with subspecialty certification in interventional radiology. He is an assistant professor at Georgetown University Hospital's Interventional Radiology Fellowship program. Since 2015, he has served as the CMO of Azura Vascular Care and on the Fresenius Medical Care corporate medical advisory board. In addition, he is the medical director of HealthQare Associates, an Azura affiliated center, where he continues his clinical practice in interventional radiology. 

NORMA J. OFSTHUN, PhD
Senior Vice President, Data Governance, Fresenius Medical Care

Norma Ofsthun leads FMCNA's data governance efforts and chairs the company's Data Governance Program. She has collaborated with numerous Fresenius physicians and outside collaborators on a variety of research publications in the renal field. Over the past 20 years, Norma's team has provided data and reports for key clinical initiatives such as the conversion from reuse to single-use dialyzers, the development of electronic algorithms for drug dosing, and the current AKI program. Norma holds her doctorate in chemical engineering from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and holds numerous patents related to membrane-based medical devices.

References

  1. Malas MB, Canner JK, Hicks CW, et al. Trends in incident hemodialysis access and mortality. JAMA Surg 2015 May;150(5):441-48. doi:10.1001/jamasurg.2014.3484.
  2. Drew DA, Lok CE, Cohen JT, Wagner M, Tangri N, Weiner DE. Vascular access choice in incident hemodialysis patients: a decision analysis. J Am Soc Nephrol 2015 Jan;26(1):183-91. doi:10.1681/ASN.2013111236.
  3. Latif W, Horowitz I, Maddux D, et al. Vascular access time based process metrics as a novel identifier in the dialysis access care continuum. In Abstracts from the 2016 Vascular Access for Hemodialysis Symposium. Chicago, May 12-14, 2016. Abstract 1.1.3.2. http://www.vasamd.org/_resources/documents/events/2016Symposium/ VASA%20Symposium_ABSTRACTS.pdf.
  4. Latif W. Transitioning dialysis patients from catheter to permanent access. Nephrology News & Issues June 27, 2016. https://www.healio.com/nephrology/vascular-access/news/online/%7Beaf6df7a-1e5b-49d1-b0c1-07baccb1cf53%7D/ transitioning-dialysis-patients-from-catheter-to-permanent-access.
  5. Dobson A, El-Gamil AM, Shimer MT, et al. Clinical and economic value of performing dialysis vascular access procedures in a freestanding office-based center as compared with the hospital outpatient department among Medicare ESRD beneficiaries. Semin Dial 2013 Sep-Oct;26(5):624-32. doi:10.1111/sdi.12120.
  6. Hull JE, Elizondo-Riojas G, Bishop W, Voneida-Reyna YL. Thermal resistance anastomosis device for the percutaneous creation of arteriovenous fistulae for hemodialysis. J Vasc Interv Radiol 2017 Mar;28(3):380-87. doi:10.1016/j. jvir.2016.10.033.
  7. Rajan DK, Ebner A, Desai SB, Rios JM, Cohn WE. Percutaneous creation of an arteriovenous fistula for hemodialysis access. J Vasc Interv Radiol 2015 Apr;26(4):484-90. doi:10.1016/j.jvir.2014.12.018.
  8. Lawson JH, Glickman MH, Ilzecki M, et al. Bioengineered human acellular vessels for dialysis access in patients with end-stage renal disease: two phase 2 single-arm trials. Lancet 2016 May;387(10032):2026-34. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(16)00557-2.
  9. Liu FX, Ghaffari A, Dhatt H, et.al. Economic evaluation of urgent-start peritoneal dialysis versus urgent-start hemodialysis in the United States. Medicine (Baltimore) 2014 Dec;93(28):e293.
  10. United States Renal Data System. 2018 USRDS annual data report: epidemiology of kidney disease in the United States. Bethesda, MD, National Institutes of Health, National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases.
  11. Ibid.